'I'm not a fan': Former referee questions whether VAR will work in Irish League after historic decision
Former Irish League referee Raymond Hetherington says he’s “not a fan” of VAR and insists local governing bodies should “either go all in or not at all” after confirming the controversial system will be used in next month’s BetMcLean Cup final.
VAR has been rolled out across world football and will be utilised for the first time within the professional game in Northern Ireland when Linfield meet Glentoran at Windsor Park on March 15.
While Irish FA officials will be in charge as normal for the showpiece decider, VAR operations will be managed by referees from outside Northern Ireland using the Hawk-Eye system, as used in FIFA and UEFA competitions.
NIFL CEO Gerard Lawlor acknowledged the decision “will not be universally popular” and many fans have voiced their concern about VAR being introduced into the Irish League.


Hetherington enjoyed 10 years refereeing in Northern Ireland’s top-flight – he officiated the 2017 Irish Cup final between Coleraine and Linfield – before stepping away in 2018.
The Dungannon native understands why NIFL and the Irish FA would be keen to introduce VAR in order to keep up with leagues across Europe, but is worried how a streamlined version would look in the Irish League.
"If you're only going to have a handful of cameras for a match here, you'll still miss things, so what's the point?” he said. “For something like that, you have to either go all in or not at all – I'm not a believer in doing things by half measures.
"We only have so many full-time teams so whether the money is there or not, I don't know.
"I'm not sure how much money the IFA would have for it, but UEFA and FIFA could maybe help implement the system. If they did, it would be a big help and you could put in a better system.
"The Irish League is the best standard (of officiating) in this country, but whether or not the quality is there or not remains to be seen.
"I was refereeing when they introduced fifth and sixth officials behind each goal line, I did a Setanta Cup final with those, and it was a complete waste of time.
"If you look throughout the rest of Europe, all the leagues are going towards it so to trial it and see how it goes won't do any harm, but I don't know whether it will work or not."
Having refereed hundreds of Irish League matches, Hetherington is well aware of the demands placed on officials and believes the on-field team should nail the majority of decisions without requiring technology.
"I'm not a fan of VAR,” he added. “I'm an avid Man United supporter and you can't really even celebrate goals because you're waiting for a possible offside or foul in the build-up, suddenly six minutes later the goal is cancelled.
"I was a referee for 10 years in the Irish League and was always a believer that if you're good enough to be there and work with your two assistants and fourth official, who are all mic'd up, you should get the right decision more times than not.
"I don't believe you need VAR with the speed of our game. I know in England it's more professional and quicker so I can see why they're doing it, but I'm not a fan of it."
