Irish League manager 'would be really open' to idea of 'fascinating' All-Ireland League

Coleraine manager Ruaidhri Higgins admits he “would be really open” to the idea of an All-Ireland League involving teams from the Irish League and League of Ireland – but is leaving those big decisions up to officials.

In 2019, Kerry businessman Kieran Lucid led the proposal of a 14-team top-flight division which combined the best sides from either side of the border.

At the time, Lucid told Reuters: “I think there would be many benefits. There are winners all around, even UEFA would benefit as they have four big leagues in Europe and it will probably be good for them to see some consolidation from smaller leagues to try to be more competitive. I think everyone wins from this, I really do.”

However, the Irish FA confirmed it wouldn’t sanction any of its clubs taking part in the competition proposed by Lucid with income figures “highly speculative and lack specificity or guarantees”.

Current Coleraine manager Ruaidhri Higgins playing in the 2012 Setanta Cup final for Derry City against Crusaders. (Photo by Darren Kidd/Presseye)placeholder image
Current Coleraine manager Ruaidhri Higgins playing in the 2012 Setanta Cup final for Derry City against Crusaders. (Photo by Darren Kidd/Presseye)

The concept has remained a talking point amongst supporters with many highlighting both positive and negative elements to a potential change.

Higgins has now coached in both the League of Ireland – he spent over three years in charge of Derry City – and the Irish League after taking on the top job at Coleraine in May.

His playing career also included spells in both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, and while Higgins is intrigued by what a combined league could look like, he’s not giving it much thought at this stage.

"My personal point of view is it would be an amazing product, there would be serious interest in it from a revenue point of view, TV deals, I think the game would become more of an industry,” he said. “There's loads of positives for it, but it has been muted for years and years.

"What will be will be. It would be fascinating, interesting, financially the game would grow on the island and there would be some ding-dong games.

"I would be really open to it, but bigger boys than me will make those decisions and we will accept what comes our way.”

A more likely scenario could be the potential return of a competition similar to the Setanta Cup, which ran between 2005 and 2014, while Dundalk defeated Linfield in the sole edition of the Champions Cup in November 2019.

One major stumbling block could be both leagues operating across different playing calendars and Higgins believes that issue would need to be resolved before pushing ahead.

"I personally think the seasons would have to be aligned to have a really good cup competition,” he added. “If the seasons were aligned, it would be a brilliant idea, but I don't see how it would work other than that because regardless of where it's at, one league is going to be in a better spot in terms of timing.

"The only fair way to run that would be if the seasons were aligned, that would be my view on it."

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice