Dermot Nesbitt: ​Windsor Framework is clearly in breach of international law and must be challenged

Recent international developments, with resulting positions and arguments for international law to be adhered to show the hypocrisy of European action when it came to Northern Ireland post-Brexit.

Sir Keir Starmer said international law ‘is the benchmark for any government around the world’placeholder image
Sir Keir Starmer said international law ‘is the benchmark for any government around the world’

The biggest challenge in 2026, as stated in this paper’s editorial on December 31, 2025 is: “the continued trading difficulties imposed on our hard-pressed businesses under the Windsor Framework” and when “more EU rules come into effect.”

Also, Owen Polley (​Politics set to be as turbulent in 2026 as it was last year, January 5) stated: “Unfortunately, the unionist parties seem increasingly out of ideas on what to do about it.”

The reality is, and has been, there is a clear and forceful argument to expose the challenge of the Windsor Framework. It’s rooted in international law. Territorial integrity and political independence of states have long been accepted as fundamental principles of international law, in order to preserve peace and stability. Northern Ireland is no different from elsewhere as to how it should be treated.

When the NI Protocol (later the Windsor Framework) came into effect on January 1, 2021, the lack of adherence to international law in NI was actioned. Regarding the fundamental principle of international law, with respect to the territorial integrity of the state, the ordinary and natural meaning is clear: ‘respect’ (recognise and abide by) and ‘integrity’ (the state of being whole and undivided). The Windsor Framework clearly breaches this fundamental principle.

The record will validate I endeavoured to get unionism’s leadership to make this argument.

I was acutely disappointed that prior to January 2021 no consistent reference was made to the importance of international law relating to the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement being in breach of international law. Unionism’s leadership then and now needs to speak with one voice and have a clear, simple and focused position, argued with consistency, conviction and clarity at every opportunity. Regrettably, it has failed to do so.

The vision is clear, the message simple; we say yes to the same rights, same stability and same principles of government that operate elsewhere in Europe.

This is the projection of a strong positive argument. It is not a triumph of unionism over nationalism but rather the triumph of logic, reason and equal treatment with fellow Europeans over narrow-minded dogma. To be positive and at the same time rigorously defend the Union is not contradictory - unionism’s leadership can and must do both.

Also, such arguments do not impact at all on the necessity of accommodating cultural diversity and differing aspirations in NI. I recognise differences and wish for the whole community to work and live together peacefully. I’ve held moderate views all my political career.

But today, I am deeply angry with the many calls regarding supporting the principles of international law, given that the USA captured the Venezuelan president on January 3 and president Trump wishing to own Greenland: see the following examples.

The prime minister (C4 News, January 5) stated: “That’s why, consistent with our allies, we are making the argument that international law is the benchmark for any government around the world.”

And in a special debate on Venezuela in the House of Commons (January 5), foreign secretary Yvette Cooper stated: “The commitment to international law…is immensely important to this government. That commitment to international law is part of our values; it is also strongly in the UK’s national interest.” Interestingly, the words ‘international law’ were referred to 114 times in this debate.

Also in a joint statement by European governments (January 6) regarding the concern about the future of Greenland; its security must be achieved: “by upholding the principles of the UN Charter, including sovereignty, territorial integrity and inviolability of borders. These are universal principles, and we will not stop defending them.”

In summary there were, given Brexit, solutions to preserve the integrity of the UK, but they were and are being ignored. Yes, NI politicians have several major issues to consider such as: efficiency of services, and managing the budget, but a stable foundation on which to build progress is also required.

And in a wider world, given the volatility of president Trump and attempts to secure peace in Ukraine; who knows where we go in the coming period. NI, even the UK generally, may become a bystander as events unfold.

But in this labyrinth of these concerns, the major concerns of the Windsor Framework must be addressed. There is a strategy to challenge them. To unionism’s leadership, I say - please act.

​

Dermot Nesbitt is an ex-Ulster Unionist MLA and Stormont minister

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice