Editorial: ​Tories were far too accepting of international law in saga over over Chagos Islands surrender

​The Tories are attacking Keir Starmer over the Chagos Islands surrender and Labour is blaming the previous government.

​Arguably the real culprit in this saga is the cross-party acceptance that there has been of international law.

Morning Viewplaceholder image
Morning View

Such legal frameworks are not necessarily illegitimate: the Geneva Convention emerged out of the horrors of the Second World War, and had its origin in earlier conventions. If the atrocities of 1939 to 1945 did not lead to an attempt to establish global norms and boundaries, then nothing would do.

But the convention, and similar institutions and agreements like the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) and United Nations, arose out of the ashes of two world wars but have proved badly ill-suited to 21st century challenges such as mass immigration.

With regard to Chagos, Downing Street yesterday defended the government’s work on its agreement and put the spotlight on the previous Conservative government: “They made the key concession of offering to give up sovereignty, from which there was no coming back.”

At the heart of the current stalemate was the failure of the last government to push back enough against a 2019 International Court of Justice advisory opinion against Britain on Chagos from a panel that included a Chinese judge who had been an official in that brutally repressive, undemocratic country. How grotesque for China to sit in judgement of the UK when – for example – it has flouted Britain over Hong Kong. Such nonsense brings international law into disrepute, as does Ireland backing racist South Africa in an international case against Israel that has delighted the savages of Hamas.

Northern Ireland has seen up close the flaws in international law, with the ECHR cited to justify legacy probes that (in effect) help the IRA. The UK above all should be wary of external legal constraint.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice