John Wilson Foster: No amount of betrayal by British government would induce unionists to want to leave the UK

The second excerpt from John Wilson Foster's new book asks: What would Irish unification entail for the Republic?

Leinster House in Dublin, which houses the parliament of Ireland. Those implementing moves towards unification would have to quickly acquire a knowledge of northern unionismplaceholder image
Leinster House in Dublin, which houses the parliament of Ireland. Those implementing moves towards unification would have to quickly acquire a knowledge of northern unionism

In the event of serious discussion about a unified Ireland, all-Ireland participation in the Great War, Ulster's defining participation in the Battle of the Somme, and Northern Ireland's industrial contribution to the struggle against Germany in the Second World War (the same Germany that Irish republicans approached for help in both wars), would demand equality in the telling.

Southerners whose forebears over centuries served in the British Army and Navy might support this project of redress, not least those whose grandfathers and great-grandfathers faced disgrace when they returned to the Irish counties at wars' ends. And the redress would probably divide the population of the south.

Then there is the question of the Republic's official refusal to take sides in times of war, which is in stark contrast to the historic unionist fidelity to Britain's military record. The former leader of the Ulster Unionist party, Steve Aitken, said that in the unlikely event of a united Ireland, unionists would demand the end of Irish neutrality. In our dangerously changing geopolitical world, the Republic is already coming under pressure inside and outside its borders to abandon its strict neutrality.

John Wilson Foster, originally from east Belfast, is professor emeritus at the University of British Columbia. He is the author of 20 books on natural history, RMS Titanic, and Irish and British literature and culture.placeholder image
John Wilson Foster, originally from east Belfast, is professor emeritus at the University of British Columbia. He is the author of 20 books on natural history, RMS Titanic, and Irish and British literature and culture.

Besides, Irish neutrality in terms of home defence is a proxy evasion. As Conor Gallagher puts it in Unherd: “Nato protects Ireland without the need for any potentially divisive national debate”. But that debate would have to occur in the Republic if unification came under serious consideration. Gallagher's title is ‘The Myth of Irish Neutrality’ and this myth, for which he offers copious examples from recent history, would have to be dragged into public view. This part of the Irish national story would need radical updating.

placeholder image
Read More
John Wilson Foster: Ireland's story would need to be retold in order to avoid th...

Beyond military intervention, the Republic is certainly not impartial in international crises. Since the Hamas massacre of Jews at the Re'im music festival in October 2023 and Israel's military response, the Irish government has maintained its strenuous anti-Israel, pro-Palestine policy, the Irish president, taoiseach, political parties and commentators all berating Israel.

The Republic's anti-Israel foreign policy is repugnant to unionists who have been solidly pro-Israel for some time for a variety of reasons. This difference has cultural roots, involving among other things the very different attitude to Jews in modern Irish Catholicism (with its foreign policy legacy) from that of Irish Protestantism.

Any unification debate would have to confront this deep divide with its geopolitical ramifications. An all-island debate with foreign policy on the agenda might reveal that the Republic's policy of military neutrality and diplomatic partisanship in the troubled Middle East theatre might not, in fact, receive unanimous support among the southern populace.

Those implementing moves towards unification would have to quickly acquire a knowledge of northern unionism. One recent example of ignorance of unionism: nationalists appear to believe that unionists who voted Remain in the Brexit referendum were indirectly voting for a united Ireland. They fail to understand that no amount of betrayal by British governments induces many unionists to want to leave the UK for union with the Republic.

To demand unity with others whom you don't truly know or want to know or empathise with, or respect (and real unification would require all of these) means unification is really annexation in revenge and triumph, what political scientists call irredentism.

In his recent book on unification, Brendan O'Leary refers to the culture of contempt among Ulster Protestants towards Irish Catholics. I certainly remember that in the past, the contempt being the companion of fear.

But surely the refusal of nationalists to engage with intellectual unionism is its own species of contempt. Do nationalists believe such a thing as intellectual unionism exists? Or do they believe the loyalist subculture of bonfires, semi-secret organisations, Orange parades and flags is the whole of unionism? I have yet to read anything that even implies the contrary.

In fact, unionist culture is a regional inflection or dialect of British culture, which is unionists' own culture, London their cultural and national capital, and the panorama of British history their own history.

T S Eliot once explained in a metaphor how a major new work of literature changes the tradition by likening the work to a new passenger entering a lift, causing the occupants to shuffle in space to accommodate the newcomer.

Thus far, even those unificationists generous enough to suggest “accommodating” the Britishness of unionists seem to imagine a process that requires little or no repositioning of those already in the 26-county elevator.

Canada in trying to achieve reconciliation between its French and English populations, and now between its indigenous and settler populations, has had to redefine the Canadianness they all share in common, as everyone in Ireland shares Irishness. New constitutions and laws had to be framed, new perspectives and historical interpretations accepted.

The onus for the equivalent concessions lies with the Republic of Ireland which is the constitutional entity demanding unification with a smaller population that would prefer not to.

Then there are the established dynamics of reconciliation and unification movements elsewhere. There would have to be apologies from the south for any past discrimination and excesses of nationalism, including pro-IRA support, if it wishes to secure unionist apologies for unionists' own past sectarianism and paramilitarism, though in his Nobel acceptance speech, David Trimble began such an apology.

Do those calling for a unification debate, a referendum campaign and a border poll, and who are determined to dismantle Northern Ireland, realise that the current as well as past realities of Irish society will come under the lamp – and not just the realities of British oppression of the Irish and Protestant discrimination against Catholics, though unionists must acknowledge these?

What intentions are there in the south to reinforce the third, east-west strand of the Good Friday Agreement by giving institutional body to the reality of the daily gravitational pull of British society on Irish lives and the innumerable “British characteristics” of southern society? This would help allay unionist fears. How can those demanding a unified island separate from the UK explain away the fact that London is the capital of all of Ireland in various realms of culture?

It would have to be explained, too, how the intimacy of Irish-English social relations (facilitated by the generous Common Travel Area, whereby hundreds of thousands of southern Irish happily live, work and vote in the UK), could possibly justify a destabilising of the archipelago in order to found a 32-county republic.

A republic, moreover, that cannot be truly sovereign because its finances and foreign policy and many domestic policies are set in Brussels.

Shouldn't a deep reset of the Ireland-England relationship precede any constitutional change in the Northern Ireland-southern Ireland relationship?

Even in Canada, after all the necessary exertions, there is no guarantee of success in holding the country together. The national consciousness of Quebec is stronger than ever. The indigenous people are developing something of their own national consciousness in demanding autonomy. And recent mass immigration has upset existing balances as it has in the United States, the UK and several European countries. And now, too, in the Republic of Ireland. That the Republic could absorb several hundred thousand northerners, reluctant at best, hostile at worst, and maintain social and political cohesion seems preposterous in the light of the current unrest (which yet might prove seismic) over immigrants, asylum-seekers and infrastructure crises.

Before Brexit, Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland were coming together in a shared home place. Those of a Catholic or nationalist background were even taking the lion's share of the capital city's administering. Who knows where this might have led in a generation once Northern Ireland was sincerely made to work, unionists no longer felt besieged, and the campaign for unification parked?

Is that emerging pre-Brexit convergence achievable, and if so, would it not be a solution to our predicament, perhaps for a generation, perhaps for good?

Otherwise, if the unwise and disruptive unification campaign persists, I'm tempted to put a menacing traditional Chinese spin on Bob Dylan's line in his great dark lament, ‘Mississippi’: “Things should start to get interesting right about now”. I hope southern onlookers are also listening.

l John Wilson Foster, originally from east Belfast, is professor emeritus at the University of British Columbia. He is the author of 20 books on natural history, RMS Titanic, and Irish and British literature and culture.

l ‘Ireland Out of England and Other Inconveniences’ is available by Belcouver Press, £10.99 from Colourpoint Books, Amazon and bookshops, and for £5.99 from Amazon Kindle.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice