Owen Polley: Uncomfortable truth is that Scotland now mirrors worst aspects of Northern Ireland’s politics
Nicola Sturgeon claimed last week she was ‘the victim’, after her husband was convicted of fraud. It was an unconvincing attempt to recast an incident that focused a fresh spotlight on the antics of the SNP.
In Northern Ireland, many of us have close connections with Scotland and feel that we have a lot in common with people there. We regard them as our closest cousins, if not our brothers and sisters.


That sentiment is often reciprocated, but not always.
There is a condescending type of Scot who treats our province, and its supposed ‘sectarianism’, with undisguised disdain.
This, ironically, may be because of the many social divisions and attitudes that we share. Northern Ireland has usually been cited, by haughtier Scottish commentators, as an example to avoid.
The uncomfortable truth, though, is that politics in Scotland have increasingly come to resemble the worst aspects of politics here.
That’s got nothing to do with the Orange Order, or other organisations that Scots liberals tend to demonise. It is down to the SNP and its separatism, combined with the effects of devolution.
The conviction of Peter Murrell, the party’s former CEO and the estranged husband of ex-first minister Sturgeon, was extraordinary on its own terms. But it was even more interesting because of some of the things it illuminated about Scottish nationalism.
The SNP has had to attract votes from every corner of society, to become dominant at Holyrood.
The party’s hardcore supporters, though, can resemble the followers of a cult.
This has allowed it to survive repeated serious controversies and make a mess of government, without getting blamed by its electorate.
Murrell and Sturgeon became something like Scots nationalist royalty, thanks to their role in the SNP’s election success. They wielded an enormous and almost unquestioned influence in Scottish public life.
The SNP never endorsed violence, of course, but there are parallels with Sinn Fein.
It is almost impossible to imagine behaviour from the Shinners, for example, that their most enthusiastic followers would not excuse or even endorse.
The rules that apply to the rest of us, as we’ve often seen, do not seem to apply to republicans. In Scotland, this sometimes seemed to be the case for nationalists, under the SNP.
The nastiness that separatism has injected into Scottish society is another similarity.
The current first minister, John Swinney, attracted headlines recently when he implied that critics of Sinn Fein should ‘move on’ from the violence of the Troubles and effectively forget about IRA terrorism.
Even relatively recently, with separatist poison already coursing through Scotland’s political blood-stream, this kind of intervention would have been unthinkable.
Scottish nationalists retained enough decency to distance themselves from anti-British fanatics like Sinn Fein.
That restraint is now largely gone from the SNP.
In part, this is because populists who describe themselves as progressives have become more radical, across the whole UK. You can see it in pro-Palestinian attitudes that border on support for Hamas, extreme views on race and gender and the adoption of jargon about colonialism that was once associated chiefly with terrorists or their apologists.
The SNP’s relative silence after hooliganism marred Celtic’s league title celebrations was another minor tell-tale sign and, for those who have been watching Scotland closely, the double-standards were predictable.
This party was previously, at least, keen to appear law-abiding and respectable. It now seems to be comfortable tacitly legitimising the antics of the Green Brigade, Celtic’s loutish ultras. In Northern Ireland, meanwhile, Sinn Fein has helped make the most feral forms of Irish culture mainstream among a younger generation.
Likewise, both parties are determined to impose a kitschy, Gaelic form of national identity on the places they govern, regardless of whether people want it or not.
The final parallel is more directly political. The SNP’s tactics in Scotland, since devolution, have been to deliver gimmicks and freebies that are not available in England, while blaming its failures to run Holyrood competently on Westminster.
These grievance-mongering tactics have been depressingly successful.
In Northern Ireland, Sinn Fein repeatedly blames the national government for everything, to the extent that ‘it’s all the Brits fault’ has become a running joke about its ministers. Unfortunately, most Stormont parties, including unionists, fall into similar habits, even when they do not share republicans’ aim of stoking resentment about the Union.
The SNP’s latest election manifesto was particularly flagrant, pledging to cap food prices, deliver £2 bus tickets and even give 18-year-olds £200 to spend on ‘culture’, without explaining properly how it would pay for these baubles.
Meanwhile, under nationalist government, Scotland’s once highly respected education system is turning into an embarrassment and its drug problem has become the worst in Europe.
A similar process has affected devolution in Northern Ireland.
Stormont has offered things like free transport passes, free prescriptions and no water rates, but many of our public services are becoming practically unusable and our infrastructure has decayed so much that it is hampering the economy.
None of this is intended to mock smug Scots, who claimed that our society was a throwback, while theirs was forward looking. Many of us agreed that our politics were far too insular and had deep problems.
It gives me no pleasure to point out, though, that the SNP has created plenty of the same issues in Scotland, enabled by devolution and the resentments that it feeds. Whether at Stormont or Holyrood, we should all demand better.