Editorial: Ireland has long pushed exaggerated claims about the nuclear risk from Sellafield

News Letter editorial on Monday December 29 2025:

​We report cabinet papers today that reveal that Ireland considered suing the UK over scares at its nuclear plants.

Morning Viewplaceholder image
Morning View

​The legal threat is telling for a number of reasons.

First, while defenders of Ireland would presumably say that it was only defending its own interests, any legal action would have in fact reflected an Irish grievance tendency towards Britain.

It would have also reflected a wider ignorance about nuclear power, that has latterly even affected a country as hitherto scientific and rigorous as Germany. And it highlights a unionist failure to get to grips with such wider matters of interest.

With regard to the specific Irish concerns in the 1990s, John Bruton – admittedly one of Ireland’s most impressive prime ministers and one of its least anti British – raised with John Major concerns about the Sellafield plant in Cumbria, after safety incidents in the 1990s, as well as an incident involving a Magnox reactor in Wylfa, North Wales, and indeed an incident at Dungeness, well away from Ireland, in Kent.

Sellafield has for decades been the subject of ill-founded, indeed almost superstitious, concerns as to the risk it poses to Ireland. There has never been any proof of either an increased risk of cancer caused by negligible, low-level radioactive waste in the Irish Sea, or indeed a serious risk of atmospheric fallout even in the event of a calculated attack on the site. Republic of Ireland experts in such risk have confirmed that dangers are low, yet Sellafield has been a long source of grievance in a country that is currently launching a hypocritical legal action against the UK on legacy.

In fact, Ireland has none of the carbon free benefits of nuclear power because it will not even contemplate having its own plants. And it has to import power, some of it ultimately nuclear generated.

Meanwhile, unionists rarely point this out or make the scientific case for nuclear.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice