Alliance Party a 'disgrace to innocent victims' - backlash over justice minister's 'empathy' with some terrorist perpetrators

A claim by Stormont’s justice minister that terrorist perpetrators can also be victims – and comments that she is not “incapable of empathy” with some involved in the Troubles – has been branded “appalling”.

Naomi Long defended her party’s decision to back Sinn Fein on removing the word “innocent” from a definition of a victim during a Stormont debate – saying there are “many people” who both carried out violence, and were victims of it.

Justice Minister Naomi Long has been criticised on her position that some terrorist perpetrators are also victims.placeholder image
Justice Minister Naomi Long has been criticised on her position that some terrorist perpetrators are also victims.

The Alliance leader said “everyone who has a basic need in terms of their recovery, in terms of dealing with their trauma” should be “able to access the service”.

In an interview with the BBC’s Nolan Show she said that wouldn’t “change the moral authority” about whether their actions were right or wrong – but said “to try to exclude people” based on what they had done at another point in their lives is “a dangerous road to go down”.

Pushed by Mr Nolan on how a bomber or a killer can be a victim at the same time, Mrs Long said she wasn’t “incapable of empathy” with people who got involved in violence during the Troubles.

“Often really bad things have also been done to those people, and that’s part of how they came to the point where they were willing to do those things”, the justice minister said.

Asked why perpetrators are being defined as a victim, Mrs Long said: “Well, because in certain cases, they are. So if you, for example, lost a member of your family, and you lost that member of your family, and that radicalised you into doing something that otherwise you might not have done.

“You're a victim from the loss of the member of your family. You're not a victim in the context of what you've done. If a member of your family dies at the hands of somebody else, of course, you're a victim, but if you go on to perpetrate crime in that context, you're not a victim.

“So those are the complexities that many people will have been both of those things throughout their lives”.

Ulster Unionist MLA Doug Beattie told the News Letter it “was an appalling contribution” from Mrs Long – saying she “clearly tried to blur the lines between victim and perpetrator”.

The Upper Bann MLA added: “She then went on to attempt to codify this stance by using early life experiences as a justification for terrorist acts.

“This comes on the back of Alliance Party backing a Sinn Fein amendment removing the term ‘innocent victim’ from a DUP motion as they continued to perpetuate the notion terrorists were victims.

“I have been absolutely clear, if you are a police officer, a soldier, a civilian, a terrorist or a politician and you commit and illegal act then you are a perpetrator.

“If you are the individual harmed by that illegal act then you are the victim.

“Application of common sense is needed here and victims will be disheartened to hear our justice minister take such a stance”.

Ann Travers, whose sister Mary, 19, was shot dead by the Provisional IRA outside a Catholic church in Belfast, posted on social media: “I can’t sleep tonight because [of Naomi Long’s] car crash interview on [the Nolan Show] mind you, I don’t sleep most nights because I have nocturnal panic attacks. Ms Long and the Alliance party are an absolute disgrace to innocent victims!”.

The terror gang had targeted the family because Ann and Mary’s father Thomas was a judge. He was shot six times, and an attempt to murder his wife failed when the gun jammed.

Thomas Travers said afterwards that at least one of the murder gang was a member of Sinn Féin – who defended the attack on a member of the judiciary as “directly related to the political situation in Ireland” and claimed Mary’s murder was an accident.

A DUP motion in the Assembly on Tuesday – focusing on holding the Irish government to account over its role in the Troubles – faced an amendment by Sinn Fein sought to remove the word “innocent”. The republican position was backed by the Alliance Party.

Paula Bradshaw, South Belfast MLA for the self-styled cross-community party, said that Sinn Fein’s amendment “better places the emphasis on the lived experiences and realities of victims and survivors here”. The TUV said it was “Sinn Féin rewriting history, aided and abetted by Alliance” – while the DUP called her a “Sinn Féin stooge”.

However, Ms Bradshaw said “Do you not think that I find absolutely abhorrent what the IRA and others did to Northern Ireland? I hate it every day. I want to see reconciliation”. The TUV’s Timothy Gaston retorted “You are going to vote with them.”

The Alliance MLA said she was voting for “an amendment that puts victims and survivors at the centre”.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice