Any internal DUP probe into bullying allegations ‘will be meaningless’
Any DUP probe into allegations of bullying and sexism will be “meaningless” and a “whitewash” unless conducted by someone from outside the party, it has been claimed.
Newry, Mourne and Down councillors Glyn Hanna and Kathryn Owen have urged an independent probe into the matters they raised as they left the party.
DUP leader Edwin Poots on Monday described the resignations as “peripheral” but said he would “continue to reach out to people”, adding he did not wish to lose anyone from the party.
Deputy leader Paula Bradley denied a purge is being carried out against dissenting voices and also rejected allegations of bullying and sexism linked to the leadership contest that saw Mr Poots elected as the successor to the ousted Arlene Foster.
However, Ms Bradley conceded that it may have been better to have conducted the controversial vote to ratify Mr Poots at a meeting of the party executive last month by secret ballot.
The North Belfast MLA, who was elected deputy leader in the same contest that saw Mr Poots assume the leadership, defended the party after a trio of resigning members made a series of incendiary allegations.
Mr Hanna, Ms Owen and former Westminster election candidate Diane Forsythe, who is Mr Hanna’s daughter, are among a number to have left the party amid a bitter row over the removal of Mrs Foster and the subsequent election of Mr Poots.
They claimed they were victims of a purge.
Ms Bradley responded: “There’s been some unfortunate things that have happened, resignations that have happened, but I would definitely say we aren’t going through a purge.”
The latest resignations followed a move to remove Mr Hanna as the chair of the DUP South Down Association, and Ms Forsythe as secretary, at an AGM meeting at the weekend.
Announcing his decision to quit, Mr Hanna alleged some party members faced intimidation and bullying at the meeting of the DUP executive in Belfast last month, when Mr Poots’ election was formally ratified.
He claimed some of those who raised their hands in support of holding a secret ballot on the ratification were told to take their hands down.
Ms Bradley said she did not witness any such scenes at the meeting but she pledged to investigate the claims.
She said a secret ballot may have been a better way to conduct the ratification vote.
“If there had been a secret ballot, Edwin would still have won the secret ballot but, yes, if it had calmed what we have now, well then yes of course, with hindsight, absolutely,” she told BBC Radio Ulster.
However the pair expressed cynicism over the promise of an investigation.
Mr Hanna told PA: “I suspect it’ll be a sham, a whitewash, that’s my honest opinion.
“It’s a token gesture, for it to be meaningful, I don’t know how they are going to do that. When you bear in mind, the people that are going to investigate this, a lot of them, are the ones who committed all of these bullying acts, so how can those investigate themselves.
“If they are going to go down that road, they need to bring someone in from the outside and do it that way. I don’t want it to be a sham, a whitewash or meaningless.”
Ms Owen added: “I genuinely from the bottom of my heart hope that it is sincere, that people’s concerns are taken seriously, and even from phone calls I’ve received today, these issues are still being raised today at senior levels … lets hope something good comes out of this, and that’s all I want.”
Earlier, Mr Hanna said there had been “open and unashamed bullying” by some in the party.
Ms Owen added: “It is apparent to me that there is a purging of Donaldson supporters, and it is only a matter of time before this continues across the party.
“It would be against my principles as a veteran, mother and independent woman to stand idly by and allow this behaviour to continue, rewarded by my silence and inaction.
“I have concerns over the future direction of the DUP, with many talented women and moderate individuals within the DUP feeling voiceless.
“The only way to stop this coercion and control is to remove the fuel that feeds it and empower those voices.”
In a statement, Ms Forsythe said she had faced “disrespectful attitudes” within the party, including “shameful sexism, ageism and the underlying tone of bullying”.
She said the bullying was now in “plain sight”, with members’ families “bullied and smeared” during the leadership contest.
“I can no longer be a part of this party in its journey to derail my precious country of Northern Ireland in this its centenary year,” she said.
She added: “The disintegration of this party in recent times has left me no option but to leave.
“The leadership of this party chose not to listen, chose not to acknowledge the divide in the party and repeatedly voiced their view that we need to ignore our differences and do what the leadership says.
“The public ousting from all who supported Sir Jeffrey Donaldson in Assembly posts was bad enough, but the local treatment of my father was an absolute disgrace.”
Ms Forsythe concluded: “The DUP have taken a path catastrophic for unionism and I can only hope that it can be recovered in some way by other means.”
Defeated leadership candidate Sir Jeffrey said it was highly regrettable that “senior and valued members now feel the DUP is no longer a warm house for them”.
“I fear that if Edwin fails to quickly get a grip of this situation, then many others may also conclude that the DUP is no longer capable of being a broad church and providing a home for the type of unionism we espouse,” he told the Belfast Telegraph.
On a separate issue, Ms Bradley insisted that she had not been forced to backtrack on comments last week urging the party to stop blocking a paper on commissioning abortion services from being considered by the Executive.
The deputy leader suggested she had realised herself that her remarks were not in line with party policy.
“I am not infallible in some of the things I say,” she said.
A message from the Editor:
Thank you for reading this story on our website. While I have your attention, I also have an important request to make of you.
With the coronavirus lockdown having a major impact on many of our advertisers - and consequently the revenue we receive - we are more reliant than ever on you taking out a digital subscription.
Subscribe to newsletter.co.uk and enjoy unlimited access to the best Northern Ireland and UK news and information online and on our app. With a digital subscription, you can read more than 5 articles, see fewer ads, enjoy faster load times, and get access to exclusive newsletters and content. Visit https://www.newsletter.co.uk/subscriptions now to sign up.
Our journalism costs money and we rely on advertising, print and digital revenues to help to support them. By supporting us, we are able to support you in providing trusted, fact-checked content for this website.