Elon Musk among the international figures voicing dismay over Leo Varadkar's hate crime bill as pressure group Free Speech Ireland redoubles efforts to get it scrapped

Elon Musk has once more voiced his disquiet at Leo Varadkar’s planned new hate crime law, as a pressure group called Free Speech Ireland redoubles its efforts to halt the proposed law.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

The News Letter has previously reported on both the bill and the opposition to it, including Mr Musk’s past objections to it; full details here:

In short though, the bill seeks to criminalise what it called “incitement to violence or hatred against a person or a group of persons on account of certain characteristics”, meaning things such as race, gender, religion, and “descent”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
CEO of Tesla, Chief Engineer of SpaceX and CTO of X (formerly Twitter) Elon Musk (photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)CEO of Tesla, Chief Engineer of SpaceX and CTO of X (formerly Twitter) Elon Musk (photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)
CEO of Tesla, Chief Engineer of SpaceX and CTO of X (formerly Twitter) Elon Musk (photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images)

It also seeks to create an offence of “condoning, denying or grossly trivialising genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and crimes against peace” (which has given rise to the question of whether Sinn Fein, one of the bill’s supporters, would fall foul of the new law due to its glorification of the Provisional IRA).

This week an organisation called Free Speech Ireland – which was founded by students in University College Cork in 2018 – has launched a campaign called “bin the bill”.

In a statement, the group said: “Across Ireland our message will be displayed on billboards and social media platforms informing the Irish public of the threat that hate speech legislation poses to their right to free expression.”

It also quoted its chief executive Sarah O’Reilly as saying: “Helen McEntee’s legislation threatens to criminalise individual citizens for the mere possession of material deemed to be offensive, even if they had no intention of sharing it with others if they cannot prove this to be the case.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"This innocent until proven guilty framework is fundamentally incompatible with the principles of our democracy.

“Worryingly, this bill is likely to also impact freedom of speech across Europe and even the world, as it will make social media firms like X and Meta beholden to Irish censors.”

Helen McEntee is the minister for justice, serving under taoiseach Leo Varadkar, who is also the leader of her party, Fine Gael.

Among those voicing opposition to the bill in the last few days has been Mr Musk (169m Twitter followers), who reposted one of Free Speech Ireland’s videos, adding the comment: “Destroying freedom of speech means destroying democracy.”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

UFC fighter Conor McGregor (10.4m followers) tweeted that he had signed a petition in support of the group, while author Michael Shellenberger (834,000 followers) tweeted: “Please share these posts and follow @FreeSpeechIre!!!”