It is outrageous that the Labour government of a sovereign UK is giving Ireland joint control of the legacy of the Troubles, says the DUP leader Gavin Robinson

​The Labour government has behaved “outrageously” by allowing Dublin to have “dual control” of dealing with the legacy of the Troubles, Gavin Robinson has said.

The DUP leader was speaking ahead of his party’s conference on Saturday, and with a new deal between the UK and Ireland set to be revealed today on the handling of the legacy of the violent past.

DUP leader Gavin Robinson MP speaking to PA Media at DUP HQ on Dundela Ave in Belfast this week said: "The Irish government do not have an equal say in how we, as a sovereign nation, deal with the legacy of our past". Picture: Liam McBurney/PA Wireplaceholder image
DUP leader Gavin Robinson MP speaking to PA Media at DUP HQ on Dundela Ave in Belfast this week said: "The Irish government do not have an equal say in how we, as a sovereign nation, deal with the legacy of our past". Picture: Liam McBurney/PA Wire

The two governments will publish a long-awaited framework to deal with the past, in which unionist fears of a joint role for the Republic seem set to be confirmed.

The Labour government has boasted of its re-set in relations with Dublin, despite the latter suing it over the now shelved plan of the previous Tory administration to introduce a conditional amnesty for historic killings.

Northern Ireland Secretary of State Hilary Benn leaves 10 Downing Street, London, after a cabinet meeting this week.  He has “completely misstepped on legacy” said Gavin Robinson. Pic: James Manning/PA Wireplaceholder image
Northern Ireland Secretary of State Hilary Benn leaves 10 Downing Street, London, after a cabinet meeting this week. He has “completely misstepped on legacy” said Gavin Robinson. Pic: James Manning/PA Wire

The Irish premier Micheal Martin said a “substantive package” had been agreed which would include the restoration of civil cases (almost all of which have so far been against the UK security forces).

Mr Robinson said: “I think how it has been handled has been outrageous.”

He added: “In allowing dual control of our legacy policy to the Irish government, inviting them in to have dual control of our legacy policy is egregious.

“It takes no account whatsoever of their role during the Troubles, of how they supported and protected terrorists who fled to their jurisdiction, it takes no account of the fact they frustrated extradition and criminal justice and the opportunity of answers for victims in Northern Ireland.”

Meanwhile, the News Letter today runs an essay by a legacy group (click here) which challenges the chief commissioner of the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission (NIHRC), Alyson Kilpatrick, for what they say is her campaign against former RUC officers being allowed to serve on the legacy investigative body (Irish nationalist complaints against the current legacy investigations unit are one reason why the UK has sought to reach an agreement with Dublin).

The barrister Austen Morgan, human rights activist and loyalist Jamie Bryson write that that an “elaborate” NIHRC legacy document this week “focused specifically on trying to justify the controversial and politically partisan comments of Alyson Kilpatrick its chief commissioner which had targeted the appointment of Peter Sheridan ICRIR’s Commissioner for Investigations and the independence of Sir Declan Morgan, its chief commissioner”.

In an interview with the PA news agency, Mr Robinson said about legacy: “I think how it has been handled has been outrageous. This Labour government campaigned on a policy and a manifesto of repeal and replace.

“They are not repealing and they are not replacing. What they are talking about is tinkering and strengthening the ICRIR.”

He added: “In allowing dual control of our legacy policy to the Irish government, inviting them in to have dual control of our legacy policy is egregious.

“It takes no account whatsoever of their role during the Troubles, of how they supported and protected terrorists who fled to their jurisdiction, it takes no account of the fact they frustrated extradition and criminal justice and the opportunity of answers for victims in Northern Ireland.

“It takes no account of, to this day, their failure to engage properly and open up their books to the Omagh Inquiry in a way which would answer what they could have done to answer questions and potentially avert the atrocity of Omagh.

“It does nothing to remove the outrageous interstate case they have against the United Kingdom.”

Mr Robinson said Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn had “completely misstepped on legacy”.

He said: “I don’t think he has built up a rapport with victims in Northern Ireland, we hear continuously that while they have been listened to they have not been heard. They feel let down by Hilary Benn, they have expressed that over the last year and three months.

“That is how long they have been taking to tinker around the edges, to invite in the Irish government. All of this is a complete aberration on the language of the (2015) Fresh Start agreement.

“The Irish government do not have an equal say in how we, as a sovereign nation, deal with the legacy of our past – they do not.

“They should be consulted where appropriate and that is what the Fresh Start agreement says, but this goes far beyond.”

Mr Robinson noted that the two governments are to announce their new legacy framework while the UK Parliament is in recess.

He said: “They are doing it at a time that avoids scrutiny, they are doing it at a time whenever there is an active case going through the courts which touches on legacy; totally inappropriate.”

When Labour came to power Mr Benn said there would be a “reset of relations” with the devolved areas and the Irish government.

Mr Robinson said: “It seems to be that if the only way you can have a reset of relationships is to give the Irish what they want, then there is a fundamental problem at the heart of that.

“There were complaints and criticisms as to how the Conservative government operated, how the Conservative government engaged with the Irish. At least they stood for principles and ideals that people in this province share. I am not sure what interests Labour are sharing.”

The Labour government came to power with a pledge to replace and repeal the controversial 2023 Legacy Act introduced by the Conservatives. The act had been opposed by victims’ groups and political parties in Northern Ireland, and it led the Dublin government to launch an interstate legal case against the UK.

The Act created a new legacy body, the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR), to take over the investigation of all outstanding Troubles cases. The Act also contained an offer of conditional immunity to some suspects, but this was disapplied after legal action by bereaved families.

The new framework will be unveiled on Friday by the Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn and Ireland’s deputy premier Simon Harris. It is understood the new framework will see the ICRIR overhauled and become the Legacy Commission which will look at Troubles cases. Speaking yesterday, Taoiseach Micheal Martin said there had not been “full agreement on all issues” but that Ireland would help fund the new structures.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice