MLA slams Mike Nesbitt's health department for not releasing information related to Cass gender review
A decision by Stormont’s health department not to release information relating to the Cass Review into Northern Ireland’s gender services is “deeply suspect”, an MLA has claimed.
Mike Nesbitt’s ministry has decided to withhold a draft report and communications with the gender services expert Baroness Hilary Cass – arguing that to release it would “undermine the integrity of the policy‐making process”.


The TUV’s Timothy Gaston said it is “deeply disappointing” that the department (DoH) should “seek to hide behind exemptions in the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act to stop the public seeing what went on in terms of the production of the final paper”.
Earlier this year, Baroness Cass’s final report said that Northern Ireland’s all-ages gender service was aiming to put in place “rigorous and demanding” changes to meet Mr Nesbitt’s then commitment to be part of a controversial UK-wide puberty blocker trial.
However, the UUP minister later paused participation in that trial – and then confirmed that other controversial trans drugs for under 18s had also been stopped amid health concerns.
The News Letter submitted an FOI request to DoH, requesting Dr Cass's interim report, and any communications between the department and Dr Cass and her team in the period between receipt of the interim report, and the publication of the final report.
That request was rejected entirely, with DoH saying that it is “mindful that placing a draft into the public domain, particularly where the final version is already published has the potential to mislead and cause confusion”.
“A decision has therefore been taken to withhold the draft report and the communications between DoH and Dr Cass,” officials said.
They cited an exemption in the legislation designed to protect the freedom of officials to discuss the formation of government policy, saying the material “contains developing analysis, options, and advice that were considered as part of the policy‐making process but which do not represent the Department’s settled position”.
North Antrim MLA Mr Gaston said: “I have long been concerned about the lack of transparency by DoH when it comes to the issue of so-called gender identity. Across the UK we have seen a desire to backtrack on long-standing policies which medical opinion now agrees have the potential for long-term, irreversible harm to developing bodies.
“Yet the department refuses to answer questions about who was involved in the development of the policy or indeed even if any of them had connections to groups which are ideologically committed to the trans movement.
“Professor Cass was brought in to put a stop to the idea that policy was out of kilter with the rest of the UK and would be in accordance with best practice guidelines.
“The minister made much play of her work and indeed used the work on her report as a pretext not to answer questions on the issue prior to its publication.
“Not only was she employed to carry out her work with public money but she was engaged in an area where there is significant public concern.
“It is therefore deeply disappointing that the department should seek to hide behind exemptions in the FOI Act to stop the public seeing what went on in terms of the production of the final paper.
“Of course there is a valid argument for government to have space to formulate policy. However, this is not a blanket exemption and the fact that the department is relying on it as an excuse to withhold everything – without even considering the option of disclosure of redacted documents – is deeply suspect.”