Former Irish League star feels 'turnover of players starting to catch up' with Cliftonville
Former Cliftonville defender Colin Coates believes “the turnover of players is starting to catch up” with the Reds.
Jim Magilton’s side were beaten 3-2 by Dungannon Swifts on Friday after Adam Glenny kept his cool to slot home a last-gasp penalty.
It means Cliftonville have now won just one of their last eight Premiership matches, but they remain in the race to seal a European play-off spot – Magilton’s men are two points adrift of sixth-placed Carrick Rangers with three games in hand.
Magilton’s squad has consistently been ripped apart across recent transfer windows – only three players who started in their Irish Cup final win over Linfield in 2024 remain at Solitude.


The Reds chief has continued to lose his star talent with the likes of defensive trio Shea Kearney, Odhran Casey and Jack Keaney all departing.
Coates, who won a League Cup with Cliftonville in 2022, believes the constant departure of top players is having a big impact on his former club.
"They seem to be struggling for any real momentum and form,” said Coates on BBC Sportsound. “The last two goals for Dungannon were poor from a Cliftonville perspective, there's no getting away from that.
"The turnover of players at Cliftonville is starting to catch up with them, you look at the players from my time there, it's only really Jonny Addis, Joe Gormley and Rory Hale left from that squad.
"To replace the calibre of player which has left, it's so, so difficult to do on what I imagine isn't a huge budget compared to others in the league.
"That's maybe coming home to roost a bit for Cliftonville and Jim needs to get a couple of wins under his belt to get a bit of confidence into what is now quite a young squad (compared) to what they had previously."
Magilton has enjoyed significant success at Solitude, reaching four cup finals since taking over in 2023, and has once again guided Cliftonville to another Irish Cup quarter-final this term – they’ll travel to Loughgall next month.
They recorded a third-placed Premiership finish in his first campaign, but slipped to seventh last term and will be hoping to seal a top-half return this time around.
Former Irish League manager Dean Shiels sympathises with the position Magilton is in and feels Casey’s departure to Shelbourne in January was a particular blow.
"That comes from the success they had in the cups and when Jim first came in, they started to compete at the top-end of the table,” said Shiels. “They've lost players, Casey was a massive loss in the middle of the season.
"There's a lot of uncertainty regarding could you guess Cliftonville's line-up, there's no stability, consistency, they've changed goalkeepers, and they're still relying on Joe Gormley at this stage of his career...he keeps doing the business, but it's going to catch up with them.
"To compete at the top-end of the table. you're looking to build.
"When you start losing pieces in that jigsaw, it weakens them and they're trying to rebuild again. It just seems to be a never-ending job for Jim to rebuild the team and starting line-up every transfer window."
