Jim Magilton questions 'incredible decision' not to award Cliftonville late penalty in Ballymena United defeat

Igor Rutkowski scored for a fourth consecutive Premiership match to help seal a 1-0 triumph for Ballymena United against 10-man Cliftonville on Saturday.

The 22-year-old netted his 16th league goal in 25 matches since joining from Armagh City in January with a strike after 58 minutes at Solitude.

Hosts Cliftonville were reduced to 10 men when 17-year-old Paul Stanfield was shown a second yellow card moments before half-time on what was his first Premiership start.

Cliftonville were denied a major penalty shout in the dying seconds when David Walsh collided with Brian Healy.

Cliftonville manager Jim Magilton. (Photo by Desmond Loughery/Pacemaker Press)placeholder image
Cliftonville manager Jim Magilton. (Photo by Desmond Loughery/Pacemaker Press)

Here's what Cliftonville manager Jim Magilton said after the game:

THOUGHTS ON THAT?

“It's always difficult when you go down to 10 men, but we guarded against going very traditional, so we decided we'd go for it in 3-4-2 and it was second half and we had two fantastic chances, Liam (McStravick), and then the one at the end.

"The one at the end is an incredible decision...on a day where the referee's handed out nine yellows and one red and then the one decision, it's a penalty.

"Brian Healy's a striker, he hasn't scored a goal in however many games and his eyes lit up, he's knocked it past, there's contact, he goes over, it's inside the box, it's a penalty.

"Whether or not we score the penalty, it's a really poor decision. I think the referee should have given himself a couple of seconds.

"Even the linesman, I went in to see him, the linesman said it wasn't a penalty, it was a free kick – it was in the box and he’d the best seat in the house.

"If he's actually saying that and we've shown him the video, then that's really, really poor officiating.

"(If it's not a penalty) it's a booking for simulation, do you know what I mean? He got that all wrong.

"Rhyss (Campbell) hits the post, on another day that goes in, Brian should score, you go in 2-0 up and then you're seeing the game out, you're managing the game.

"Unfortunately we conceded a really poor goal, that sequence of events that led to the goal was poor, we got punished and then you have to go chasing.

"Listen, they showed courage and bravery, that's the very least they have to show when they turn up and play for Cliftonville.

"We felt that there was enough in the game that we could set up the way we did and at times you know you're going to have to suffer without the ball, but I thought we still kept trying to probe.

"Liam gave us energy, Joe Sheridan gave us energy, we had to make subs because lads were out on their feet and we still created opportunities to win the game...unfortunately we didn't manage to do that.”

TOUGH MOMENT FOR YOUNG PAUL STANFIELD ON FIRST START, HE’LL BOUNCE BACK FROM THAT?

"Yeah he's a fantastic lad, deserved the opportunity to play.

"He'd been suspended for so long, that was his I think only second or third competitive game. We trust the boy, we've got high hopes for him.

"He'd done so well up to that point, it was just a poor decision on the stoke of half-time.

"We were in full control of the game in terms of we had the ball and then I think Joel Thompson's kicked it away needlessly, they regroup and go long and then play off a second ball and he's lunged in, his feet are high.

"Could he (ref) have not given it? Possibly, but he decided he was going to give a yellow and ultimately that's a red.”

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice