PLAYER RATINGS: Northern Ireland's World Cup heartache but 9 and two 8s against Italy
Northern Ireland’s dream of a first return to the World Cup finals in four decades ended with Bergamo blues following a 2-0 loss to Italy.
Below are the Northern Ireland player ratings (out of 10):


PIERCE CHARLES: 8
Having missed the qualifying campaign due to injury, Charles’ return between the posts offered key saves in each half, plus welcome distribution. No chance off Sandro Tonali or Moise Kean goals.
TRAI HUME: 7
Handed the captain’s armband, one of two players alongside Justin Devenny with Premier League experience, he proved calm and controlled with some perfectly-timed clearances – especially from close to his own line following a second-half corner-kick.
RUAIRI McCONVILLE: 8
Northern Ireland’s tallest player, his height and positioning proved key as Italy looked so often to attack down his side across the first half. Was so often in the right place at the right time.
PADDY McNAIR: 6
Sole player in the starting side with previous major tournament experience from EURO 2016, McNair often a reliable presence in the backline – including one crucial second-half header with Kean waiting to convert.
TERRY DEVLIN: 7
First senior competitive start for ex-Irish League player who stepped in with some vital blocks. Milestone night cut short for tactical reasons.
SHEA CHARLES: 9
Driving force putting Italy on the backfoot with his energy and confidence in possession across a commanding performance up against engine-room opponents from Juventus, Inter Milan and Newcastle United.
JUSTIN DEVENNY: 6
Delivered a teasing corner-kick off Northern Ireland’s first of the match that flashed across the face of goal just begging for a decisive touch.
BRODIE SPENCER: 7
Early racing back to cut out the threat of Kean typified his energy and athleticism at both ends and also crucial to help disrupt Mateo Retegui’s big sight of goal after the interval.
ETHAN GALBRAITH: 6
Probing and always seeking to prove inventive but will rue missed opportunity in first half to slip in Isaac Price during a rare golden chance to hurt the hosts.
ISAAC PRICE: 6
Part of Northern Ireland’s midfield energy so key to Michael O’Neill gameplan but unable to offer the attacking threat behind a double-figure goal return in international colours.
JAMIE DONLEY: 6
Often dropped deep from attack during the initial stages to help defensively and proved a willing runner. Unfortunate not to be able to take advantage of Gianluigi Donnarumma miskick at 1-0.
Sub (used):
PAUL SMYTH (on for Devlin, 69 mins): 5 – No opportunity to show his attacking strengths.
JOSH MAGENNIS (on for Donley, 79 mins): 5 – Introduced to offer goal threat but second conceded within seconds on the pitch.
JAMIE REID (on for Spencer, 79 mins): 5 – Unable to influence with Northern Ireland at 2-0 down.
Subs (not used): BAILEY PEACOCK-FARRELL, CONOR HAZARD, EOIN TOAL, TOM ATCHESON, GEORGE SAVILLE, CALLUM MARSHALL, PATRICK KELLY, BRAD LYONS, CIARON BROWN
