Evidence over Ideology: Northern Ireland’s curriculum reform is long overdue
A child’s access to an excellent education should never depend on the school they attend or the opportunities their family can afford. Every pupil deserves the knowledge to understand the world, the confidence to question it and the opportunity to succeed.


That is why I believe Northern Ireland’s curriculum reform is not only welcome, but long overdue.
TransformED offers us an opportunity to bring greater clarity and coherence to what children and young people learn. I welcome its direction. But its success will ultimately be judged not by the language of policy documents, but by what happens in classrooms - particularly for pupils whom our education system has too often underserved and put at disadvantage.
Having taught Key Stage 3 Science, I have seen one of the problems first-hand. The current statutory curriculum simply does not give teachers enough precision.
Put plainly, it is a wishy-washy document.
It is not sufficiently clear about the essential knowledge pupils should acquire, the depth in which it should be taught or the sequence learning should follow. Teachers can therefore find themselves asking very basic questions: What exactly must I teach? How much detail is enough? What should pupils already know before I begin?
A statutory curriculum should help answer those questions.
Teachers work incredibly hard to turn broad statements into meaningful lessons, but they should not have to reinvent the curriculum in every school. Professional judgement matters enormously; so too does a shared understanding of what every child in Northern Ireland is entitled to learn.
Lucy Crehan’s independent review of the Northern Ireland Curriculum, published in June 2025, strengthened the case for change. It identified significant weaknesses in the existing framework, including a lack of specificity and coherence, and recommended much greater clarity about the knowledge, concepts and skills pupils should acquire as they progress through school.
That matters because high aspirations are not enough. We also need a clear account of what we intend to teach.
Build the foundations first
In my previous article, I raised concerns about what I describe as a “top-down” approach to learning: expecting pupils to understand complex ideas before they have secured the knowledge needed to understand them.
We would not expect a child to read fluently before they understood how letters and sounds work. Nor should we expect a pupil to evaluate a scientific claim when they do not yet understand the science behind it.
Think about it another way.
Imagine boarding a plane and being told that one of the passengers is going to fly it. They have never flown before, but not to worry - they are going to learn through discovery.
Nobody would accept that.
We understand instinctively that flying requires expert instruction, modelling, supervised practice and gradual independence. A classroom is obviously not a cockpit, but the underlying principle is worth considering: novices need guidance from people who know more than they do.
That is where teachers matter.
Teachers are not simply facilitators standing at the side of the classroom while pupils discover everything for themselves. They bring subject knowledge, pedagogical expertise and professional judgement. Their job is to explain unfamiliar ideas, model successful approaches, identify misconceptions and gradually move pupils towards independence.
Independence should be the result of good teaching, not the starting point.
This is where I believe some interpretations of “child-centred” education deserve greater scrutiny. Listening to pupils, understanding their needs and encouraging them to participate actively in learning are all important. But that is very different from expecting children to determine the sequence or discover the substance of unfamiliar learning for themselves.
When pupils are given too little guidance, learning can become an exercise in guessing. Those who already possess strong prior knowledge may find their way through. Those who do not can be left wondering where to begin.
That is hardly equitable.
Knowledge and thinking are not enemies
We frequently hear that education should prioritise critical thinking, creativity and problem-solving. I agree that these are important ambitions.
But pupils need something to think about.
A pupil cannot critically evaluate a business decision without understanding the relevant business concepts. They cannot challenge a scientific explanation without enough scientific knowledge to recognise where it might be weak. Creativity does not emerge from an empty head.
Knowledge and thinking should not be placed in opposition to one another. Knowledge gives pupils more with which to think.
That brings us to one of the most important debates surrounding curriculum reform: equity.
I understand the argument that a more demanding, knowledge-rich curriculum could favour grammar schools. If expectations are increased without giving schools and pupils the support needed to meet them, that concern deserves serious attention.
But I disagree with the suggestion that clearly specified, ambitious knowledge is somehow inherently better suited to pupils in selective education.
Why should demanding ideas belong to one school sector?
Why should a pupil attending a non-selective school have any less entitlement to substantial subject knowledge than a pupil attending a grammar school?
High expectations should not be the preserve of the already advantaged.
A coherent curriculum can help by identifying the essential knowledge every pupil should encounter and making progression much clearer. It can create greater consistency across the system so that a child’s access to important knowledge depends less on how broadly worded curriculum statements happen to be interpreted in their particular school.
That does not mean every teacher delivering identical lessons at exactly the same pace. Nor does it mean removing professional judgement.
It means establishing a common educational entitlement while allowing teachers to decide how best to help the pupils in front of them reach it.
Equity does not mean treating everyone identically
Of course, pupils are different.
Some will require additional explanation. Others will need adapted resources, more modelling or further opportunities to practise. Pupils with special educational needs may require highly individualised approaches and, where appropriate, personalised learning goals.
A common entitlement does not require identical provision.
Indeed, equity requires us to recognise those differences.
The ambition of curriculum reform therefore has to be matched by the support required to make that ambition achievable.
This is particularly important for children experiencing disadvantage. Some pupils grow up surrounded by books, educational visits, conversations about current affairs and access to additional tuition. Others depend much more heavily on school to provide access to knowledge and experiences beyond their immediate environment.
When essential knowledge is left implicit, we risk assuming that children already know things they may never have had an opportunity to learn.
Explicitly identifying and teaching that knowledge makes fewer assumptions about what children bring through the school gates.
For that reason, I see a clearer curriculum not as a threat to non-selective education, but as an opportunity. It can make a pupil’s entitlement to important knowledge more transparent and more dependable.
What does this mean in the classroom?
Curriculum reform is only worthwhile if it is accompanied by effective teaching.
Rosenshine’s research-informed principles offer useful guidance here: introduce new material in manageable steps, provide clear models, ask questions, check understanding and guide pupils through practice before expecting them to work independently.
Regular review then helps pupils retain what they have learned and connect it to new material.
None of this means classrooms should become places where pupils sit silently while teachers talk at them.
Discussion matters. Collaboration matters. Practical investigation matters. Creativity matters.
But their effectiveness depends on when and how they are used.
A practical investigation is more meaningful when pupils understand the scientific ideas they are investigating. A classroom discussion is richer when pupils have knowledge to contribute. Independent work becomes genuinely independent when pupils have first been taught what they need to know.
Pupil autonomy should therefore grow alongside pupil expertise.
More content is not automatically better
There is, however, an important warning for those of us who support a more clearly specified curriculum.
A knowledge-rich curriculum must not become an overloaded curriculum.
Simply adding more and more content would be a mistake. If teachers are forced to race through enormous amounts of material, pupils may encounter plenty but understand little.
Curriculum design is therefore as much about what we choose to leave out as what we choose to include.
Depth matters. Sequence matters. Time to practise matters.
The proposed Northern Ireland Curriculum 2028 gives us an opportunity to get that balance right. The involvement of local teachers and subject specialists in developing the proposals is particularly important. Those working in classrooms understand the difference between something that looks impressive on paper and something that can actually be taught well.
But implementation will be everything.
Teachers need time to understand the changes, plan collaboratively and develop high-quality resources. Schools need clear assessment guidance. Professional learning needs to be sustained rather than reduced to a one-off training day.
Goodwill alone cannot carry reform of this scale.
Evidence over ideology
Finally, if we are serious about putting evidence over ideology, that principle must apply even to reforms we support.
Calling a policy “evidence-informed” should never end the discussion. It should begin it.
What evidence supports the approach? What are its limitations? What happens when it reaches real classrooms? Are pupils learning more? Are they retaining more? Are gaps narrowing? Do teachers have the resources and support to deliver it effectively?
And, crucially, are the pupils who have traditionally been least served by our system benefiting?
Those are the questions that should determine whether reform is working.
I support the direction of curriculum reform because clearer content, coherent progression and expert teaching can provide a stronger foundation for educational opportunity.
But its promise must extend to every school and every pupil.
Northern Ireland’s children deserve an ambitious education. They deserve teachers who are trusted as experts. They deserve a curriculum that tells us clearly what they are entitled to know while giving professionals the freedom to teach it well.
And they deserve an education system in which high expectations are not determined by postcode, school type or family income.
That is the opportunity now in front of us.
Change is coming - and it is long overdue.