Owen Polley: Stormont has repeatedly let down health workers by ducking reform
Unfortunately, like many thousands of other people in Northern Ireland over the past few months, I needed the help of our National Health Service last weekend.
On Saturday, I fell off my bicycle and smashed my left wrist. As a result, firstly I was sedated and given a procedure to stabilise and reposition the bone. Then, the next morning, my joint was rebuilt during several hours of surgery at Royal Victoria Hospital.
I’ve written about the NHS quite a bit over the years. But an up close and personal experience always helps put things in a sharper perspective.
That’s primarily because, as a patient, you can’t help but be struck by the kindness, dedication and professionalism of almost every member of staff you meet in hospital.
They really are remarkable people, with reserves of caring and empathy that most of us can only wonder at.
It’s all the more impressive that they display these qualities under such challenging circumstances.
For example, the nurses who show endless reserves of patience through the small hours of the night while they are abused and sometimes even threatened by distressed patients. These are often older people, confused and delirious, who are not in any way responsible for their behaviour, but they still say hurtful, potentially intimidating things. It’s a special skill to be able to deal with that, calmly and firmly, in the middle of a busy shift.
When you are in hospital receiving care, you see that staff are working incredibly hard, often without breaks, while remaining helpful, interested and sympathetic to every patient. But there are difficulties with the system too. It is busy and struggling to cope.
I was unfortunate, or perhaps not, that I had an open wound on my broken joint. There was a risk that it would become infected and that was why I had my operation quickly. The surgeons were blunt that, if it hadn’t been for the cut, I would probably have had to wait much longer.
Indeed, many patients were waiting considerable lengths of time, some of them in terrible pain, for essential operations on broken legs, hips and other bones or joints. The lists for emergency surgery are long and growing.
There is clearly considerable pressure on beds, with some people waiting in discomfort in A & E or in inappropriate wards or bays. But, at the same time, it can be a lengthy and frustrating process being discharged, even after that decision has been taken and plans have been made to fill the bed.
Everybody’s doing their jobs with the utmost professionalism, but there are snags and bottlenecks that hold everything up and give an impression of inefficiency.
For an explanation, we have to go back to Stormont and the failure of successive health ministers to reform the NHS in Northern Ireland. Since at least 2011, and the Transforming Your Care report, but arguably as long ago as 2001 when the late Maurice Hayes published his recommendations, experts have repeatedly pointed out what needs to happen.
We know that there should be a smaller number of acute hospitals with a greater concentration of expertise and more resources should be directed at providing care in the community. In addition, there are difficulties with staffing, particularly in certain jobs and specialties.
Rather than act on these requirements, the executive at Stormont repeatedly delayed taking necessary but potentially unpopular decisions.
In 2014, the Donaldson Report made specific recommendations to close facilities and reorganise services. It was parked, due to one of Stormont’s periodic crises, and when the assembly got back to some sort of normality, in 2016, the new minister, Sinn Fein’s Michelle O’Neill, commissioned a new review, Bengoa, which made broadly the same points, but presented them in more general terms.
It’s an endless, circular process sustained by politicians who refuse to take responsibility for difficult decisions, like closing smaller hospitals. The latest incumbent at the health ministry, Robin Swann, has had to deal with Covid, so you can understand perhaps why reform has not taken priority, but no great change seems imminent. Remember that, just before coronavirus arrived, in December 2019, there was already a nurses’ strike and medics predicted that the system was close to breakdown.
The pattern is clear, and Stormont’s refusal to act has allowed NI’s NHS to become outdated in comparison with services in the rest of the UK. Our politicians have let down its brilliant employees badly and repeatedly.
Indeed, the crisis in health offers a neat case-study of many of the inbuilt problems with our devolved institutions. Their tendency to encourage shirking responsibility, thinking only about the short-term, taking the easiest choices and ignoring more difficult ones, blaming everybody else.
Unavoidably, the unionist parties’ most pressing problem at the next election is the protocol. However, in terms of making Stormont work, an honest, responsible approach to government that confronts long-term problems, rather than denying or ignoring them, is something that voters will think is long overdue.
• Henry McDonald Oct 9: Colm Toibin spurns misty-eyed guff about a ‘New Ireland’
• Ben Lowry Oct 9: Echoes of 2019, as Boris Johnson fails to proclaim his unionism in speech
• Ruth Dudley Edwards Oct 5: The bigotry of Michael D Higgins shocked some - I’m sad to say I wasn’t one
• Peter Robinson Oct 1: Doug Beattie should say to where he wants UUP voters to transfer
• Other articles by Owen Polley below, and beneath that information on how to subscribe to the News Letter
• Owen Polley Oct 2: Unionists must stay united against the disgraceful Northern Ireland Protocol
• Owen Polley Sep 27: The UK should stand up to the US without fear over Northern Ireland
• Owen Polley Sep 18: Dublin would be horrified if faced with an all-Ireland state
• Owen Polley Sep 13: Unionists still seem muddled about the harm done by NI Protocol
• Owen Polley Sep 4: Unionism needs leaders who set the agenda
A message from the Editor:
Thank you for reading this story on our website. While I have your attention, I also have an important request to make of you.
With the coronavirus lockdown having a major impact on many of our advertisers - and consequently the revenue we receive - we are more reliant than ever on you taking out a digital subscription.
Subscribe to newsletter.co.uk and enjoy unlimited access to the best Northern Ireland and UK news and information online and on our app. With a digital subscription, you can read more than 5 articles, see fewer ads, enjoy faster load times, and get access to exclusive newsletters and content. Visit https://www.newsletter.co.uk/subscriptionsnow to sign up.
Our journalism costs money and we rely on advertising, print and digital revenues to help to support them. By supporting us, we are able to support you in providing trusted, fact-checked content for this website.