Robbie Butler says Gerry Carroll's bid to oust Stormont's education minister is 'hypocrisy at full throttle'
An attempt to oust Paul Givan as education minister was “performative, divisive, and deeply hypocritical”, the Ulster Unionist Party’s deputy leader has said.
Robbie Butler also slammed the MLA behind the motion – People Before Profit’s Gerry Carroll – over a social media post on the day of the October 7 attack by Islamist terrorists on Israel in which he said “Victory to the Palestinian Resistance”.


Mr Butler said that was “hypocrisy at full throttle” and “tells us all we need to know about the double standards at play”.
He was speaking as the Assembly debated a motion to remove Mr Givan from office for a year – the strongest sanction for a minister available to MLAs.
“We are told that this motion is brought because the Minister of Education ‘failed to uphold and support the rule of law’ and ‘breached the Ministerial Code of Conduct’. In truth, this motion tells us far more about the state of politics in Northern Ireland than it ever will about Paul Givan or Israel.
“It is performative. It is partisan. And worse than that, it is misleading the public. Let’s call it what it is, political theatre dressed up as moral outrage”, the UUP MLA said.
The Lagan Valley representative said the lives, education, and futures of Palestinian and Israeli children are all of equal worth – and while some had supported the motion out of genuine conviction, they had allowed themselves to be “drawn into alliance with those who would spin sincerity into spectacle”.
He said Sinn Fein were “eager to reclaim the territory staked out by Mr Carroll”.
“Some of their own members have met with Hamas representatives, individuals who openly boast their involvement in acts of terror, and they now presume to lecture other others on moral responsibility and rule of law”, Mr Butler said.
TUV MLA Timothy Gaston said the motion was a poor attempt at Punch and Judy politics – saying it was “the art of left wing political theatre, with Gerry Carroll writing the script”.
He said the censure motion was for exceptional circumstances – and criticised its supporters for not instead referring the matter to the independent Assembly Commissioner for Standards.